|
PL SC 014
Monday, April 5th, 1999
Announcements: All
Dan's sections have a quiz on Friday on North and South America
Lecture notes:
I. Definitions of War
A. Standard - a realitively severe violent confrontation
between military forces
representing two or more states
1. Must have state status
2. Civil War is treated
differently
B. Karl von Clausewitz
1. 19th century Prussian
strategist
2. Widow published his
incomplete notes after his death
3. He had three defintions
of war
a. War is a continuation of politics by other means
-war is politics because their goals are the same
b. War is nothing but a duel on a larger scale
c. In the whole range of human activities war is best represented by a
game of cards
4. He did not focus well
on how states act during war
5. He was the best at
looking at war analytically
6. All his definitions
are good, but are not coherent
II. Theories of War
A. Systemic
1. Power based
2. War is about power
3. Theories for causes
of war focused until recently
4. The first three are
based on the balance of pwer
5. System is a unit of
anylasis
6. States are important
actors
B. Balance of Power (Standard)
1. War occurs because
one state is trying to becomes dominant, and the other
becomes the other states for coalitation
2. All states fight for
room in system problems occurs when one state fights for
dominance
a. What happened during W.W.II
III. Bipolar Balance of Power
A. Kenneth Waltz
1. Balance of power works
most efficiently with two states
2. When you have two
states that cancel each other out
3. Least effective with
more states involved
4. Good example wa the
Cold War
5. The most stable system
B. Multipolar
1. Most stablewith more
than two dueling states
2. Kaplin and Singer
3. After Napoleon era
4. Many strong countries
5. No one wants to fight
against strong corallations
C. What the difference is between two theories?
1. Bipolar is more likely
to act unrational
2. Multipolar- more likely
you are who does not want war
D. More uncertain you are about the conflict,
the more adverse the conquences
IV. Power Transition Theory
A. Period when Mediterranean is Roman
Empire rules ,
B. One big and powerful country with
the other small students
C. Hegemony
D. Big State realizes they can get
their way
E. Predicts war in a specific way
(Example: W.W.II) Great Britian and Greece
F. Reseachers try to find examples to fit one
theory, more than others
1. None really work
2. Theories tell you
when states compete; if they will win
3. Limited empirical
applications
4. Beaucray uses theories
to rationalize
5. According to theories
it tells how to determine
V. State-level
A. Set of rules, who is most powerful
B. Divisinary (Wag the Dog)
1. A leader engages in
an international conflict in order to differ attention from
domestic problems.
a.
Expect to occur
b. Usually go like this when there is a democratic government
2. Stalin -domestic unrest,
shot his opponents
a. Democracies are more likey to fight
C. Democratic Peace
1. Democracies are just
as likely to fight as other states, just not with each other
2. Democracies share
similar ideologies
3. Most democracies are
richer and therefore depend on free-trade
4. They don't have anything
to fight about--- they tend to have similar values and
opponents
|